• Vocals on "A Story I Trust", "Dueling (Reprise)", "Inconceivable", "Pit of Despair", "King of Everything", "Do You Hear It?", "Miracle Max", "The Plan", "Inigo Montoya", "Finale" (A Story I Trust Reprise)", and "Curtain Call (As You Wish Reprise)" by Treyan Porter
• Vocals on "As You Wish" by Anna Belle Holley and Jacob Grossenbach
• Vocals on "Dueling" by Jacob Grossenbach and Will Baggett
• Vocals on "I Will Never Doubt Again" by Anna Belle Holley
• Vocals on "Dueling (Reprise)", "Pit of Despair", "Do You Hear It?", "Miracle Max", "The Plan", "Inigo Montoya", "Finale" (A Story I Trust Reprise)", and "Curtain Call (As You Wish Reprise)" by Jacob Grossenbach
• Vocals on "Pit of Despair", "Do You Hear It?", "Miracle Max", "Finale" (A Story I Trust Reprise)", and "Curtain Call (As You Wish Reprise)" by Anna Belle Holley

"A Story I Trust"

"Dueling"

"Inconceivable"

"As You Wish"

"Pit of Despair"

"I Will Never Doubt Again"

"King of Everything"

"Do You Hear It?"